Bad Medicine

Bad Medicine

China’s Groundbreaking Malaria Drug Is Losing Africa’s Trust

In 1967, as the United States sank into war in the jungles of Vietnam and China descended into the cataclysm of the Cultural Revolution, Chinese soldiers secretly fighting alongside the North Vietnamese also battled swarms of malarial mosquitoes. Showing remarkable foresight, Chinese Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong amassed a secret team of top scientists with one mission: find a cure for malaria.

As China—then a poor country, barely recovered from a devastating famine—added insult to injury by dismantling its scientific, medical, and educational institutions under Mao’s misguided program of political cleansing, the scientists labored on with clear purpose. Within a decade, some 500 researchers, many of whom were persecuted politically along the way, developed an ingenious drug called artemisinin, pulling off a medical marvel against the odds.

Kathleen McLaughlin
Coartem’s artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) is one of the many variants of malaria medication that have been copied and faked in Tanzania. The packaging is typically well-made, but there is no guarantee about the contents. This dose is for children with malaria.

The scientists and researchers of the People’s Liberation Army’s Project 523, named for its May 23 creation date, made one of China’s greatest contributions to modern medicine at the same time as Mao was destroying the foundations of China’s scientific establishment.

Mao’s great medical innovation was withheld from the world for four decades because of Chinese military secrecy and intense global pharmaceutical competition. Today, it is the key ingredient in the frontline treatment for malaria in Africa.

Yet before artemisinin even has a chance to get a foothold in the battle against malaria, the drug is in danger of becoming a casualty of China’s own overzealous profiteering and global drug counterfeiting.

In East Africa, artemisinin combination therapy, or ACT, became the preferred treatment for malaria a few years ago. Along with the massive influx of lifesaving drugs, first from European manufacturers and now from China, came a deluge of fakes.

In Uganda and Tanzania, whose lands form most of the mosquito-infested Northern and Southern shores of giant Lake Victoria, the malaria death rates are among the highest in the world. Widespread regulatory failure and unscrupulous business practices have created a market flooded with bad drugs. Coupled with China’s already bad rap as a producer of inferior goods such as cheap shoes, knock-off phones, and faulty condoms, the reputation of China’s malaria cure is perched on a precipice.

A small but growing body of evidence for the massive upswing in counterfeit medications in Africa. There is proof of bad medicine originating in China, including the recent haul in France of 1.2 million doses of fake aspirin, some bound for Africa. Until now, the deadly risk of fake medications flooding Africa has been under-studied and under-reported.

“It is an enormous problem,” says Nick White, tropical medicine specialist who leads Southeast Asia programs for Oxford University’s Wellcome Trust, which spearheads groundbreaking research on counterfeit and fake malaria drugs. “It’s not like a boil that’s begun to burst, because it’s been a problem for a long time. What’s happened is we’ve begun to recognize it more.”

The Wellcome Trust and others estimate that in Uganda, including ACTs and all others, may be fake or substandard. From the streets of Kampala to Lake Victoria’s shores, fakes are abundant. Dispensary workers are cagey when asked about fake drugs, but admit they exist and they can do little to tell which are real and which won’t work.

Thousands of private pharmacies have opened in recent years, offering quick remedies to maladies that have plagued the region for generations. The pharmacy boom has given counterfeit drug rings a major foothold. Locals routinely blame China for the bad medicine they peddle.

“I took the drugs I bought in a private dispensary when I had malaria two years ago. Nothing happened. Two days later I was still with fever, so I went to a hospital and found the drugs were probably fake,” says John Otala, a 32-year-old father of three in Kampala. “We all know everything that comes from China is fake already, so I believe they may have been Chinese.”

There is little relief. Fakes come in expertly copied packaging, down to exactly replicated logos, country-of-origin labels, and crisp foil strips, capable of fooling even medical professionals. The best pills bear the same inscriptions as real drugs, but contain little or no real medication. Only lab tests can spot the bad drugs, and testing equipment is scarce and expensive. For those with no time to wait in line for a day to see a doctor, taking malaria pills is a game of chance.

Even major Western aid agencies have been of drugs as critical as antiretrovirals for AIDS patients. As aid donations of free malaria drugs to clinics in sub-Saharan Africa rise, filling shelves with pharmaceuticals, the patient demand for pills has boomed: finally there are cures and everyone wants them. But the boom also has opened a new consumer market for bad drugs.

Experts on the global fake drug racket explain: counterfeit medications follow demand. In the United States, customers find fake Viagra. When patients hear of a new cure or treatment, demand skyrockets. In East Africa, patients need malaria medication. Tracking the trade has proven almost impossible. “The counterfeiters try everything and they try everything to hide their identities,” explains Sabine Kopp, head of the Anti-Counterfeiting and Medicines Quality Assurance Program at the World Health Organization. “It is very, very difficult to catch. Even in the studies, you only get a picture of the moment when you do the studies.”

Just how dire that picture might be for China’s homegrown malaria cures is becoming evident to the drug’s champions at home. Artemisinin’s inventors are concerned the damage will undercut the country’s great medical innovation.

Wu Yulin, a seventy-four-year-old veteran of Project 523, helped isolate the chemical structure of artemisinin in the late 1960s from an herb used as a traditional fever remedy. China used the plant for decades, but it only went global when the Swiss pharmaceutical giant Novartis bought the patent and began marketing artemisinin combination therapy (ACT) in the late 1990s. “Authentic ACT is very effective,” says Wu, who lives in Shanghai. In Africa and China, “governments need to strengthen management to crack down on fake drugs. The fakes will undermine the health of people and will definitely set back the progress and potential of this medication.”

This explosion in fake medications in East Africa did not come without warning, nor has the growing suspicion of China in Tanzania and Uganda.

As elsewhere across the African continent, China’s presence has mushroomed in Uganda in the past five years. Though there is intense debate over how to , China now is among Uganda’s top trade partners and its health aid has grown from nearly nothing five years ago.

Kathleen McLaughlin
A team of doctors from Yunnan, China perform acupuncture on patients in the $10 million Mulago Hospital in Kampala, Uganda.

China moved into Africa in its own way, with the government, state-owned companies, and private businesses all doing deals on their own terms, avoiding involvement with international organizations that work on health, education, and poverty reduction. The strategy has been both vilified and lauded as an alternative to Western-style aid, which critics say comes with too many strings attached.

In 2010, Jerry Lanier, then the U.S. Ambassador to Uganda, detailed in a diplomatic cable China’s growing engagement: “China does not currently collaborate or coordinate with the United States or other donors in Uganda on areas of seeming common interest like health.”

There is evidence this also has led to cutting corners and backdoor deals that might not be in the best interests of the most vulnerable.

China is sensitive to international criticism of its dealings overseas and has responded by developing its own health aid. Since it has all but eradicated malaria from within its own borders and created its own ingenious cure, what better place to focus than Africa?

In recent years, Beijing has promoted plans to open at least thirty malaria treatment centers across Africa. Yet the that was trumpeted by Chinese state media was closed when I visited last year, barely a year after it opened. Patients and staff said the facility was unused because doctors were not trained how to operate the equipment from China.

There is no reliable source of information to determine the number of Chinese clinics opened or shut in Africa—none except perhaps those records kept by the global drug companies whose salesmen must fill new orders each month. A primary trouble with China’s medical aid on the continent is that it has not been subject to independent oversight.

A lack of follow-through at many clinics has added to a growing negative perception of China in East Africa.

Yet some Chinese medical aid is working, particularly when it involves manpower. For example, a team of doctors dispatched from China’s subtropical, and once malaria-infested, Yunnan province to Kampala to work in a newly-funded Chinese hospital has a long roster of patients eager for their expertise and treatments like acupuncture for pain. Uganda’s health-care system suffers a serious shortage of personnel, so the Chinese doctors are filling a gap.

But even those doctors were running a private, for-profit backdoor pharmacy, undermining their purely humanitarian aid mission in Uganda. Finally, the Chinese doctors stopped selling malaria drugs when the pills became legal, according to the store manager. In other words, it was no longer a profitable sideline. The drugstore now mainly hawks libido-enhancing tea from China.

Perhaps no one is more sensitive to the issue of counterfeit medicines than China’s government. After ran in The Guardian in December, and defended its pharmaceutical industry and its aid to Africa in and in state-run media.

“China puts a premium on drug safety and fights resolutely against the production and sales of fake drugs,” Hua Chunying, spokeswoman for China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told the press at a regular briefing in December, four days after one of my articles appeared. “China follows world-recognized principles and practices in the management of medicine export, provides certificates to qualified drugs as required by the World Health Organization and adopts tough measures against fake drugs.”

That was not the case in Uganda, as U.S. Ambassador Lanier pointed out three years ago, summing up what one sees and hears on the streets of Kampala. Among Lanier’s noted “downside risks” to China’s burgeoning investment in Uganda: local resentment over fake and substandard Chinese products dumped on the local market and exaggerations by China of its efforts to improve the lives of Ugandans. “In January 2010, the Chinese Ambassador to Uganda delivered 244,000 doses of two Chinese anti-malaria drugs to Uganda at a public event that was featured in large paid advertisements in local papers,” Ambassador Lanier wrote, according to the text of a . “The donation nevertheless only amounted to about one week of Uganda’s requirements for malaria treatment.”

Of particular concern to Lanier was the misuse of Arco, a highly touted China-made brand of artemisinin combination therapy. Arco was tested on patients in Kampala but, as Lanier wrote, “had not been pre-qualified by the World Health Organization… [even though]… part of the funding for the malaria clinic in Mulago hospital was earmarked for testing of these drugs.”

Nearly two years after the delivery of Chinese drugs , Uganda’s own Ministry of Health said the drugs were safe, although the WHO had not approved them.

The deadliest problem remains counterfeiting and fakes, risking lives and threatening to kill China’s potential for real medical aid in Africa.

The global drug counterfeiting trade, a , is hidden behind layers of organized crime and by foreign governments and the global pharmaceutical industry, wary of getting on China’s bad side. But as , those two countries are the prime suspects when it comes to bad drugs.

Corruption and China’s damaged reputation are far from what the innovators of Project 523 imagined in their groundbreaking quest for a malaria cure. According to an unpublished history, New Drugs from Ancient Chinese Remedies: Unsung Heroes in Unusual Times, sent to me by the author, neuroscientist Yi Rao, and researchers at Peking University, the discovery of artemisinin by Chinese scientists in 1967 was nothing short of a wonder, given the chaos of the times.

Chinese traditional healers had been using the leaves of the sweet wormwood plant, or qinghao, for two centuries to treat malaria and fevers when Project 523 began. Though villagers in Southern China knew of the plant’s curative properties, it took the better part of a decade for government and military researchers to isolate one particular chemical and the correct dosing that would cure malaria, not kill the patient.

As Yi describes it, Project 523 was a massive undertaking, especially in a China convulsed by the destructive decade of the Cultural Revolution, a movement that ruined many other academic institutions and set back scientific research for years. Yi says the project itself withstood turmoil by pulling in hundreds of scientists and researchers, many of whom didn’t last long and were replaced as others were purged. Often, scientists would work for a year only to be replaced as they were consumed by political vendettas. “Participating institutions were spread across China, involving hundreds of individuals from Beijing, Shanghai, Yunnan, Shandong, Guangdong, and Guanxi, which borders Vietnam,” Yi wrote. “It was undoubtedly a large collaborative project with contributions from administrators, scientists, and soldiers who volunteered for tests of the early treatments.”

Chemist Tu Youyou joined the project in 1969, a time when “most senior scientists could barely survive the ‘struggles’ against them.”

Tu got most credit for the discovery, despite its having been the result of the work of fifty institutions and more than 500 scientists. In 2011, she became the first Chinese scientist working in China to receive the $250,000 , a prestigious U.S. foundation prize given for medical advances.

Malaria-focused aid groups say artemisinin and resulting ACTs are revolutionary tools for Africa, yet the intriguing tale of the drug’s invention in China and its eventual emergence as a first-line treatment is getting lost in the deadly battle against fakes and counterfeits.

Festus Ilako, Tanzania Country Director for the African Medical and Research Foundation, is confident ACTs have dramatically reduced malaria deaths and that the disease can be defeated with the drugs. Unfortunately, the prevalence of fake medicines in Tanzania, Uganda, and elsewhere across East Africa is worsening, according to medical professionals and academics.

“There’s actually quite a lot of success against malaria in recent years, mainly because there are very effective medications that are available,” Ilako said in an interview in Dar Es Salaam. “Artemisinin, when it’s used, kills 90-95 percent of the parasites.”

But when it’s fake, it cures nothing.

Kathleen E. McLaughlin is an American journalist who has been based in China for more than a decade.  She has covered everything from labor abuses to politics, economics, and social upheaval in China...

The reporting in Africa for this story was funded by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting. To see more stories in this series, click .





Rich Man, Pu’er Man

Christina Larson
“These men always have machetes,” shouts the driver. Through trees along an unpaved road, he spots a ramshackle hut, slows down, and warns his passengers: this is a checkpoint. It’s the only way to enforce rules in this part of the jungle, at the...



Sino-Russian Trade After a Year of Sanctions

Alexander Gabuev from Carnegie Moscow Center
After a year of intense flirtation, the Sino-Russian relationship is beginning to look like a one-sided love affair. Indeed, Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to China last week—his first since the United States and European Union enacted...



Parading the People’s Republic

Geremie R. Barmé
In light of the September 3, 2015, mega military parade held at Tiananmen Square in Beijing both to mark the seventieth anniversary of the end of Second Sino-Japanese War in 1945 and to acclaim the achievements of Xi Jinping, China’s Chairman of...



Is China About to Plunge the World Into Recession?

David Wertime from Tea Leaf Nation
On Aug. 18, China’s stock market plummeted by a vertigo-inducing 6.2 percent in one day of trading, part of a months-long decline that’s erased over $3 trillion worth of market value from the country’s equity markets. That followed last week’s...



Hong Kong’s Umbrella Protests Were More Than Just a Student Movement

Samson Yuen, Edmund Cheng
For almost three months in late 2014, what came to be known as the Umbrella Movement amplified Hong Kong’s bitter struggle for the democracy its people were promised when China assumed control of the territory from Britain in 1997. Originally a...



Does Xi Jinping Represent a Return to the Mao Era?

Andrew G. Walder, Roderick MacFarquhar, Susan Shirk, Orville Schell
Following is an edited transcript of a live event hosted at Asia Society New York on May 21, 2015, “ChinaFile Presents: Does Xi Jinping Represent a Return to the Politics of the Mao Era?” The evening convened the scholars Roderick MacFarquhar and...



Invasion of the Body Snatchers

Yaqiu Wang
On the morning of March 16, 48-year-old Huang Shunfang went to her local hospital located in Fanghu Township in the central Chinese province of Henan. Her doctor diagnosed her with gastritis, gave her a dose of antacids through an IV, and sent her...



Where Do We Draw the Line on Balancing China?

from Foreign Policy
Is it time for the United States to get serious about balancing China? According to Robert Blackwill and Ashley Tellis, the answer is an emphatic yes. In a new Council on Foreign Relations report, they portray China as steadily seeking to increase...



Frank Talk About Hong Kong’s Future from Margaret Ng

Margaret Ng, Ira Belkin, Orville Schell
Following is the transcript of a recent ChinaFile Breakfast with Margaret Ng, the former Hong Kong legislator in discussion with Ira Belkin of New York University Law School and Orville Schell, ChinaFile Publisher and Arthur Ross Director of the...



The City of Urumqi Prohibition on Wearing Items That Mask the Face or Robe the Body

A Proclamation from the Standing Committee of the Urumqi People’s CongressThe “Regulation banning the wearing of items that mask the face or robe the body in public places in the city of Urumqi,” which was passed at the 21st Meeting of the 15th...