Despite Regulations, Bus Travel Still Risky

Despite Regulations, Bus Travel Still Risky

Thirty-six people died recently on a Shaanxi province highway when a double-decker bus slammed into a fuel tanker.

The crash underscored ongoing demands for beefing up traffic law enforcement and improving the design of these often-crowded overnight buses, which transport nearly 180 million passengers in China every year.

Only three passengers emerged alive from the sleeper bus early August 26, when the long-distance bus collided with a truck methanol in Yan’an and burst into flames.

Authorities said a preliminary investigation found each of the bus’ two drivers were negligent. A GPS tracking service had sent them a fatigue warning just before the accident. Investigators say the driver behind the wheel was too tired.

On August 27, Shaanxi province Governor Zhao Zhengyong announced all sleeper buses would be banned from provincial roads at night for the next week while investigators probed the wreck.

Meanwhile, new questions have been raised about alleged manufacturing and design flaws in sleeper buses. Some are said to have too few emergency exits. Others are made with highly flammable materials in seat upholstery and curtains.

Migrant worker Wang Xianze, 50, was a survivor of the Yan’an crash. He planned to take the bus from Inner Mongolia to Xi’an, and then transfer to another sleeper to reach his destination, Chongqing.

When the accident occurred, Wang opened and climbed out of one of only two safety windows.

The dead included nine students, ten migrant laborers, thirteen employees of various companies, a self-employed person, and an unidentified person died, Yan’an authorities said. Both drivers perished as well.

Driving in Circles

AFP/Getty Images
In this scene from a 2011 accident, police inspect the burnt wreckage of a double-decker bus after the bus, which was carrying hazardous goods, caught fire on a highway in Xinyang, in north China’s Henan province. At least forty-one people died in the accident, while five passengers and the driver were pulled out alive from the overnight bus.

Between 2004 and 2010, 20 percent of all major traffic accidents nationwide in which more ten people died involved sleeper buses, according to the Ministry of Transportation.

Critics say regulators are quick to issue violation notices after such tragedies, but remain excruciatingly slow about enforcing safety laws.

The ministry released a notice in July 2011 that said every sleeper bus driver was required to stop driving after pulling over at a highway rest stop any day between 2 and 5 a.m. But only Jiangsu province authorities have taken clear steps toward making sure these central government safety regulations are being been followed, said a report in the Oriental Morning Post.

In March, the Ministry of Industry and Information and Technology and the Ministry of Public Security released a notice banning all production and sales of sleeper buses. They said sleeper buses would have to be taken off all roads in China within six years.

Meanwhile, though, this cheap and simple means of intercity travel remains highly popular for low-wage workers and others on a budget. A survey conducted last year by several government agencies found 60 percent of sleeper bus passengers were farmers and migrant laborers.

Currently more than 30,000 sleeper buses roll down China’s highways following more than 5,000 scheduled routes, the China Road Transport Association said.

After surviving the latest big crash, Wang was asked whether he would ever again ride a sleeper bus. “It depends,” he said.

Ren Zhongyuan, Luo Jieqi, and Liang Dongmei are Caixin staff reporters.


From the Caixin Editors

China is a nation of laws, authorities enjoy saying, and indeed government bookshelves are stuffed with them. But a toothless carnivore can’t eat much meat, and weak enforcement mechanisms have rendered all sorts of mainland regulations gnawingly ineffective. The problem is especially serious on increasingly busy back roads, where traffic safety and labor standards can be shrugged off. National laws setting working-time limits for bus drivers, for example, are clear and encompassing. But when no one with a badge is watching, which is usually and in most thinly populated areas, bus companies and drivers can feel free to ignore the laws. Occasionally, a brutal crash with fatalities occurs and forces authorities to rethink the rules. They can fine an erring bus company, imprison a driver, and add another page to a law book. But as the following report suggests, what’s needed most is enforcement.

By Ren Zhongyuan, Luo Jieqi, and Liang Dongmei



Caixin Media


Chinese Electric Vehicle Manufacturer BYD’s Image Hurt by Scandal Involving Dealer’s Suicide

China’s largest electric vehicle manufacturer, BYD Auto Co., is under intense scrutiny following the death of a Nanjing auto dealer who accused the company of bilking a government subsidy program and a Caixin probe suggesting the charge may have...

Caixin Media


Chinese Telecoms Gear Maker ZTE Fighting U.S. Export Ban

The second-largest maker of telecoms gear in China is scrambling to get off a U.S. export blacklist that threatens to dry up supplies of critical components.“The investigations are still in progress, and may result in criminal and civil liabilities...

Caixin Media


No Point in Ramping Up Personal Debt to Help Property Market

Having banks and local governments deleverage and trim overcapacity are part and parcel with central government efforts to maintain stable growth by nurturing the supply side of the economy. But even as this is happening, the housing market has been...