Toxic Effects and Environmental Nondisclosure

Toxic Effects and Environmental Nondisclosure

High-profile talk emphasizing environmental action at the Communist Party’s 18th national congress attracted a lot of attention. News from the November proceedings spurred industry demands for more information and pushed stock prices higher for companies that make environmental products.

(AFP/Getty Images)
Smoke billows from chimneys at a factory in Jilin province, November 29, 2009.

Government officials at the congress pledged to improve environmental assessment practices, strengthen accountability, and raise public awareness of the damage wrought by pollution since the 1970s while China built the world’s second-largest economy.

The promises follow reports that environmental management overall has been deteriorating in recent years, despite minor improvements. Moreover, public protests tied to environmental issues have been on the rise.

To accomplish its environmental goals, the government must insist on transparency. But so far, nondisclosure has been the norm. For example, it’s disturbing to note that results from a national land pollution survey apparently completed in 2010 have yet to see the light of day.

The study, jointly conducted by the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Ministry of Land and Resources, began in 2006 as the first of its kind. Its aim was to identify polluted sites across the country so that measures, including legislative steps, could be taken to tackle various problems.

Not only have none of the findings been made public, but essentially there’s been nothing done toward clean-ups nor helping people affected by toxic soil. Not a single individual or group has been held accountable for damage, and no new environmental protection laws have been introduced.

In addition, key details about a separate, recently introduced State Council plan to mitigate soil contamination have yet to be announced.

A presidential report released at the congress linked environmental hazards to endangering public health. It also called for stronger measures to prevent and control water, soil, and air pollution.

China’s soil contamination problem is among the worst the world has ever seen, according to data released in 2006 by the Ministry of Environmental Protection. The study found toxins affecting some 10 million hectares of the country’s 120 million hectares of arable land, and that another 2.1 million hectares of crops were being irrigated with polluted water. Some 133,000 hectares were being used for waste dumps nationwide.

It’s also been estimated that heavy metals contaminate up to 12 million tons of food—or 20 billion yuan’s worth—every year in China.

Researchers have found high levels of cadmium in the blood, urine, and hair of people in certain farming communities. A 2011 Caixin report about toxic waste in rural China said no one really knows how cadmium damages the human body, although health experts have blamed the heavy metal for poisonings in Japan linked to so-called “itai-itai” disease, which weakens victims’ bones.

Reportedly, much of the government’s documentation is outdated and thus fails to detail the full extent of the nation’s environmental problems. Thorough reports and transparency may be lacking because officials fear telling the truth would upset the “social stability” they so highly prize. But this fear is unreasonable.

Three years ago, a Ministry of Housing study of conditions in 4,000 cities found only 58 percent of the public water supplies met official health standards. But the results were withheld from the public until May, when a Caixin report forced the issue. The publication did not upset social stability but instead spurred communities to action.

Authorities should now follow up by releasing the latest soil contamination survey—as soon as possible—for the sake of the country and its people.

People have a right to know whether their urban surroundings and farms are polluted, and if so to what extent. They need this information to assess the risks they face and work out appropriate countermeasures. Transparency can also reduce public suspicions toward the government and keep protests from happening.

Disclosure is also important because policymakers at all levels need information to properly formulate preventive measures, identify polluters, and impose penalties before environmental degradation gets even worse.

At stake is the government’s credibility. Regulations on government information disclosure that took effect in May 2008 say authorities must release information to the public in a timely manner. Information covered by this rule would include details about polluted land, including its extent and locations, presented in plain language, as Beijing does by regularly releasing data about unhealthy, PM2.5 particulates in the city’s air.

The 18th congress concluded with calls for a systematic approach to environmental management, as well as proposals for holding polluters accountable and compensating pollution victims. Next on the agenda should be mandatory information disclosure.

The government can take the first step by releasing the data it’s already gathered on nationwide soil contamination. As our new leader Xi Jinping told the congress in his first speech as party chairman: “This is a national responsibility—a responsibility for the people.”

This editorial was first published by on November 28.



Caixin Media


Authorities Should Do More to Protect China’s Lawyers

A Communist Party group led by General Secretary Xi Jinping that was established to spearhead reform efforts finished a document on September 15 addressing the plight of lawyers. A day later, top judicial authorities, including the Supreme People...

Caixin Media


Xi and Obama Should Make a BIT Breakthrough

President Xi Jinping has begun his first state visit to the United States to meet U.S. President Barack Obama in what state councilor and former foreign minister Yang Jiechi has called “a pivotal meeting at a critical time.”Xi arrived in the United...

Caixin Media


Chinese Contractor Finds Project in Bahamas Is No Day at Beach

A giant luxury resort planned on a beach outside the Bahamas’ capital, Nassau, that is supposed to be a showpiece to help China’s largest construction company tap the U.S. market has become a headache for both its builder and a lender.The resort was...

Caixin Media


Stock Market Volatility Is Not a Harbinger of Collapsing Growth

It would be a sad end to an amazing story. An economic miracle—one that lifted 300 million people from poverty and shifted the world's economic center of gravity—collapsing under the weight of risky investments and a financial crisis.This seems...

Caixin Media


Amnesty As a Stepping Stone to Rule of Law

A recent amnesty declaration affecting convicted criminals deemed no threat to society was a poignant reminder of China’s tradition of prudent punishment, support for human rights, and progress toward of rule of law.The recent decision by the...

Caixin Media


Quantum Computing and Alibaba’s Leap of Faith

Building a quantum computer that processes data at speeds trillions of times faster than the world’s fastest computer, China’s supercomputer Tianhe-2, is the goal of a potentially game-changing venture launched by Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. and the...

Caixin Media


How to Solve China’s Currency Parity Puzzle?

Boosting exports, controlling outbound capital flow and supporting the Chinese currency’s bid for Special Drawing Rights (SDR) status are just some of the reasons cited by analysts for the yuan's unexpected devaluation in mid-August.The yuan...

Caixin Media


Official Stonewalling on Tianjin Explosions Sparks Outcry

While victims of the Tianjin explosions are still waiting to be told why their loved ones died or, how safe it is to go outside, officials remained evasive in the sixth press conference regarding the disaster.In response to a question from a Caixin...

Caixin Media


Auditors Probe Sinopec, Savvy Broker in Angola

Government auditors are taking a closer look at U.S.$10 billion worth of offshore oil investments by state-run China Petroleum & Chemical Corp. (Sinopec) that owe their existence to a Hong Kong businessman with a flair for networking in the...

Caixin Media


Villain or Hero for Stock Market Saga?

An obscure equities-trading finance agency that brokers often slighted in favor of bank loans has suddenly taken center stage in the drama playing out in the stock market.But reviews are mixed over whether the four-year-old, quasi-governmental China...