Why War is Not a Possibility

Why War is Not a Possibility

There won’t be a war in East Asia.

The United States has five military alliances in the western Pacific. Its allies are South Korea, Japan, Thailand, the Philippines, and Singapore. And American battleships are busy patrolling the seas.

Without a go-ahead from Washington, there is no possibility of a hot war involving battleships of sovereign countries here. As for conflicts between fishing boats and shore patrol boats, that’s not really a big deal.

The Chinese at this time have to ponder several questions: If the country has a battleship war with Japan, can it win without using ground-based missiles? Would a war escalate if missiles are deployed? What would happen if a war continues with no victory in sight?

Antoine Bouthier/AFP/Getty Images
An activist holds the Japanese flag before a group placed the country’s flag on a disputed island, part of a group known as Senkaku in Japanese and Diaoyu in Chinese, August 19, 2012.
In the past few days, one country bought the islands at the center of the controversy, and the other announced the base points and the baselines of its territorial waters. But look closely: China and Japan have at least two things in common in this hostile exchange.

At home, they fan the flames of nationalism. And in the international arena, none of their activities has exceeded the scope of previous respective claims on sovereignty.

This means there is no possibility of a war in East Asia, not even a remote possibility.

From the East Sea to the South Sea, though, China has reached a new low in its relations with Asian neighbors. It’s hard to remove the flashpoints in territorial disputes, but a country can surely reduce any impact.

The key is in the nation’s relations with the United States.

When the United States and China were warm toward each other during the first decade of this century, our ties with ASEAN were also close. As the former cooled down, the latter became marked by disputes and conflicts.

China’s external environment reached a high-water mark in 2008, when Ma Ying-jeou was elected Taiwanese leader and Sino-U.S. cooperation in the war on terror was still under way. After Barack Obama was elected to the White House in 2008, though, the two countries failed to introduce any additional positive interactions.

The idea of a G2 proved unrealistic. Bilateral relations started spiraling downward. Now, the two countries cooperate only when absolutely necessary, fight one another on a number of issues, and walk their own walks on many others. Relations look adequate on the surface, but under the surface they are frozen.

The strongest link between China and the United States used to be trade. Those relations suffered a heavy blow after the economic crisis of 2008. Trade as a card has lost its power, not only between China and the United States, but with China’s southeastern neighbors as well.

Trade can hardly act as a deterrent with Japan, too, since we are on different ends of the same supply chain. Any punishment against one will cause significant pain to the other. The weight of trade and human rights topics in foreign relations is giving way, too. Politics is thus once again pure politics.

Sino-U.S. relations are already, and increasingly, complicated. Rows between the dominant and emerging power are coupled with ideological differences. There are no easy solutions, but one can easily identify ways to prevent factors further complicating the matter.

For instance, China has no strategic interests in Syria and has no obligation to stand with Russia.

A realist must have reservations and make choices. When necessary, China should be able to forgo old friends, especially if there was never friendship in the first place.

Wang Shuo is managing editor of Caixin Media.


From the Caixin Editors

A Japanese reporter working for a Chinese news outlet we won’t name in order to protect his identity was asked to describe his impression of the tension over land spits known as the Diaoyu Islands in China and the Senkaku Islands in Japan. He called the affair, in so many words, a festival for CCTV state television talking heads and the least educated of their viewers. Not a single doctoral student in China, he thinks, would find reason for dispute. Indeed, Caixin Managing Editor Wang Shuo this week argued that all the sometimes scary media bluster, seasoned recently by small but loud street demonstrations against Japan in several Chinese cities as well as Taiwan, is significant for political reasons but will not spark war. Now that the Japanese government has bought the uninhabited islands, it seems nothing will be built worth fighting for. Yet the continuing tension has disheartened many, including the Japanese reporter. “Too much media coverage,” he said.

By Wang Shuo



Caixin Media


China Eyes More Muscle for Market Supervision

from Caixin
Strengthening the People’s Bank of China’s regulatory clout is high on a list of suggestions for improving financial market oversight following last summer’s stock market crash.As supporters of the plan see it, no government institution is in a...

Caixin Media


Government Enlists NGOs to Help Homeless

from Caixin
Drivers roll up car windows as an autumn wind chills a traffic-clogged overpass in western Beijing’s Liuliqiao area. And under the concrete overpass, homeless people are gathering for a chilly night’s rest after wandering city streets.Among the...

Caixin Media


Mao’s ‘Proud Poplar’: Yang Kaihui

Sheila Melvin from Caixin
Yang Kaihui—who was killed 85 years ago this month—was the first of Mao Zedong’s three freely chosen wives. (Mao was forced by his parents to wed an older neighbor when he was just 14 but did not consider this a true marriage.) Yang’s dramatic, and...

Caixin Media


Does the Punishment Fit the Corruption?

from Caixin
After Chen Bokui, the deputy head of a government advisory body in the central province of Hubei, was convicted of taking 2.8 million yuan in bribes by a court in the eastern province of Fujian in April, he received a somewhat stiff sentence—17...

Caixin Media


Hemingway's Literary Escape

Sheila Melvin from Caixin
One noonday in 2002, a friendly acquaintance of mine—I’ll call him Q—left his office in a Beijing concert hall to go to lunch and never returned. After a series of inquiries, his wife and colleagues learned that he had been arrested. Various charges...

Caixin Media


Moving 2 Million People for Beijing’s Urban Reset

from Caixin
Nearly 2 million Beijing residents will be moved to the city’s outlying districts from the center by 2020 as part of a massive urban revamp designed to better control people, traffic, and smog.The movers include up to 1 million government workers...

Caixin Media


Insider Trading Is Hindering Development of Stock Market

from Caixin
A series of investigations into apparent market violations emerged after the recent stock market turmoil, bringing down Zhang Yujun, an assistant chairman at the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC); Cheng Boming, general manager of CITIC...

Caixin Media


Authorities Should Do More to Protect China’s Lawyers

from Caixin
A Communist Party group led by General Secretary Xi Jinping that was established to spearhead reform efforts finished a document on September 15 addressing the plight of lawyers. A day later, top judicial authorities, including the Supreme People...

Caixin Media


Xi and Obama Should Make a BIT Breakthrough

from Caixin
President Xi Jinping has begun his first state visit to the United States to meet U.S. President Barack Obama in what state councilor and former foreign minister Yang Jiechi has called “a pivotal meeting at a critical time.”Xi arrived in the United...

Caixin Media


Chinese Contractor Finds Project in Bahamas Is No Day at Beach

from Caixin
A giant luxury resort planned on a beach outside the Bahamas’ capital, Nassau, that is supposed to be a showpiece to help China’s largest construction company tap the U.S. market has become a headache for both its builder and a lender.The resort was...