Truth in Chinese Cinema?

Truth in Chinese Cinema?

Chinese Realities/Documentary Visions at MoMA May 8-June 1

In 1997, as James Cameron’s Titanic sank box office records around the world—including in China—Sally Berger, assistant film curator at the Museum of Modern Art, worked to bring New York moviegoers a raft of Chinese movies they’d never heard of.

The fourteen films in the series were not martial arts pictures or costume dramas, but instead movies like director Wu Wenguang’s stark 1990 documentary Bumming in Beijing, which captured the lives of a group of artists struggling to find their way in the shaky aftermath of the crushed democracy movement of 1989.

Photo courtesy of Icarus Films
<em>Tape</em> (2010), directed by Li Ning.

Even when China was but the world’s eighth largest economy and barely on the minds of most Americans, Berger felt outsiders needed to understand the country better. Now China’s economy is No. 2 and stories about it hit American front pages nearly every day. Time again for a reality check.

So it is that on Wednesday, May 8, at MoMA in New York, Berger and co-curator Kevin B. Lee unveiled Chinese Realities/Documentary Visions: The Evolution of Documentary Practice in China, 1988-2013. The program of twenty-five films is set to run through June 1.

“Over the past three decades, China has been radically transformed through all kinds of economic and social changes, and it’s led its artists and filmmakers to ask, ‘What is real in our world, and how is reality constructed?’” Lee, a Chicago-based independent distributor at dGenerate Films, said. “One big part of this is the regulation of Chinese media, which leads to a version of reality on movie and TV screens that’s often unrecognizable relative to what people in China actually experience. So we selected a number of really groundbreaking films that probe deeply into this question of what is real.”

In the sixteen years since the first big Chinese film series at MoMA, Chinese filmmakers have focused either on mimicking Hollywood fairy tales—mostly badly, failing to gain traction overseas—or tried to tell their own stories about what’s really going on around them in China, often in direct conflict with officialdom eager to promote a tidy version of the nation’s smooth progress under Chinese Communist Party rule—meaning no distribution at home.

In homage to the spirit of the 1997 series, which screened several films forbidden from being shown in public in China, Wednesday’s opening night film at MoMA is director Zou Xueping’s The Satiated Village (2011), a young woman’s documentary about the elders in her village who survived the famines that killed, by conservative official accounts, some 15 million Chinese from 1958-61.

Zou, a film student, belongs to a Beijing collective founded by Wu Wenguang, which equips young Chinese filmmakers with cameras and tasks them with capturing stories typically erased from official media. Last summer, a public independent festival in Beijing that featured Zou’s film and several similarly unflinching others had to shift to a tiny private venue when the electricity to the public venue where it was being held suddenly and inexplicably shut down.

Over the next twenty-five days, MoMA will screen celebrated Chinese non-fiction films of recent years such as Wang Bing’s West of the Tracks (2003)—a three-part, nine-hour portrait of an industrial wasteland—and Zhao Liang’s 2009 Petition, an exploration, twelve years in the making, of the world of petitioners who travel to Beijing to seek justice. Also showing are milestones along the road of China’s documentary practice, films such as the 1992 drama The Story of Qiu Ju—in which director Zhang Yimou used hidden cameras to capture actual street scenes he then cut into his fictional film—and a condensed version of the 1988 television documentary River Elegy, a series that was censored after 1989 for its criticism of traditional Chinese culture as an obstacle to social progress.

MoMA also will offer up a few brand-new films—including Longing for the Rain, the first narrative feature by noted documentarian Yang Lina, the story of a Beijing housewife seduced by a phantom lover threatening to destroy her middle-class life.

For students of the global village trying to follow the development of the “real China”—that complex, fast-paced capitalist place not seen in martial arts costume dramas—an evening talk on Friday, May 10 with director Wu may be the best scene-setter. Titled “Baring your Stuff,” the talk will pair Wu with curators Berger and Lee after a screening of the film that began it all, Wu’s Bumming in Beijing.

“We are coming full circle with Wu Wenguang, whose vision of China and the possibility for Chinese cinema is as eye-opening today as when we first met in 1997,” Berger said.

A full screening and lecture schedule for Chinese Realities/Documentary Visions: The Evolution of Documentary Practice in China, 1988-2013 is available here.

Jonathan Landreth reported from Beijing from 2004 to 2012, with a focus on the media and entertainment industries' effect on the world’s perceptions of China. He was the founding Asia Editor of The...





‘Personal Media’ in China Takes a Hit From Pre-Publication Censorship

Hu Yong
Observers have long thought that Chinese authorities censor the media depending on type: the censorship of traditional media is primarily conducted in advance, with a thorough inspection of news and discussion before publication; new media, in...



Pulitzer’s ‘Lookout on the Bridge’ vs. China’s ‘News Ethics Committees’

David Bandurski
In a recent harangue on the imperative of better journalism, a website run by the Chinese Communist Party’s Central Propaganda Department tore a jagged page from the wisdom of American newspaper publisher Joseph Pulitzer: “A journalist is the...



China Censors Online Outcry After ISIS Execution

Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian from Tea Leaf Nation
On November 18, the Islamic State (IS) released photos of what it claimed were two executed hostages. The photos, appearing in the terrorist group’s English-language magazine Dabiq, depict two men with bloodied faces, the word “executed” emblazoned...



Chinese Students in America: 300,000 and Counting

Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian from Tea Leaf Nation
In 1981, when Erhfei Liu entered Brandeis University as an undergraduate, he was only the second student from mainland China in the school’s history. “I was a rare animal from Red China,” Liu said in a September 1 interview with Foreign Policy, “an...



The Real Reason for China’s Two-Child Policy: Millions of New Consumers

from Tea Leaf Nation
Two fictitious Chinese brothers are born in Tuanjiehu Maternity Hospital in the Chinese capital of Beijing. Let’s say the first was born already, in late 2015; his parents nickname him Laoda, meaning “oldest child.” That’s because they have hopes...



Good Journalist, Bad Journalist

David Bandurski
As China marked its annual Journalists’ Day over the weekend, proclaiming the importance of “correct news ideals,” even jaded New Yorkers stopped in their tracks and took notice. How could they not? The message beamed over 7th Avenue on Times Square...



Watch Frank Underwood Advertise China’s Black Friday

Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian from Tea Leaf Nation
On November 11, at the stroke of midnight Beijing time, millions of Chinese sitting behind their computers or cradling their mobile phones began purchasing cell phones, handbags, and clothing at cutthroat prices. By the end of November 11, analysts...



Chinese Hits Miss Out on the Global Box Office

Jonathan Landreth from China Film Insider
If he’d had the time after meeting American captains of industry in Seattle and Barack Obama at the White House, Chinese President Xi Jinping might have ducked out at the close of his United Nations appearance and into a New York movie theater to...



Can the China Model Succeed?

Daniel A. Bell, Timothy Garton Ash, Andrew J. Nathan, Taisu Zhang, Mark Danner, Orville Schell
Is this a new model? Is authoritarian capitalism, Leninist capitalism, something that has durability? Have the rules changed about how countries develop? That used to be, remember, that open markets led ineluctably to open societies. How does it...



‘A Brutality Born of Helplessness’

Alexa Olesen from Tea Leaf Nation
When China finally scrapped its one-child policy after more than three decades of brutality, almost no one lamented its passing. But Paul R. Ehlich, a Stanford-educated biologist and author of the 1968 fear-baiting classic The Population Bomb, was...