An Alternative Top Ten

An Alternative Top Ten

Chinese Independent Films of 2012

Most accounts of the last year in Chinese cinema are dominated by films that were made for the ever-expanding domestic box office, and the local film industry’s struggle for screen time in competition with Hollywood imports.

On the one hand, we read about Back to 1942, an historical epic about a bygone Chinese famine and the latest would-be blockbuster from perennial hit maker Feng Xiaogang and his longtime partners at the Huayi Brothers studio in Beijing. On the other hand, Chinese and now international media have been eager to report on the low-budget hit Lost in Thailand, which appeared out of the blue to claim the title of biggest Chinese-language movie hit in the short history of the nation’s modern box office.

What is absent from most stories of big-time cinema success in China is any mention, let alone celebration, of small-scale independent films. The aim of independent cinema seldom is to sell tickets. This is especially true in China, where independent films avoid or reject the censorship process the government requires to attain a longbiao, or local exhibition certificate.

Though China’s practitioners of independent film suffered in 2012, as festivals and conferences came under official pressure and often were canceled at the last minute, the informal sector nevertheless produced an impressive number of creative, beautiful, and moving new films whose existence should figure in any account in the year in Chinese movies. In honor of pictures mostly passed over by the press, here’s my alternative Top 10—a list of the best independent films China had to offer in 2012.

One documentary stands out from the rest: Three Sisters (三姊妹) by Wang Bing (王兵). Wang, China’s most important documentary filmmaker, shifts from the historical themes he has explored in the past in masterpieces such as West of the Tracks (铁西区) to a subject both intimate and immediate. His camera records the lives of three extremely poor young sisters, aged ten, six, and four who live in an isolated mountainside hamlet in southwest China’s Yunnan province. Over the course of three hours without a shred of condescension or pity, the film brings us into close confrontation with the dirt, poverty, and repeatedly backbreaking daily labor these little girls are compelled to do. Big sister Ying becomes a kind of everyday hero: laborer, cook, farmer, aspiring student, and mother to her two sisters. Wang’s powerful images manage to be beautiful and seem to capture fundamental truths: we feel as if we are seeing into an essential, grassroots kind of life that hundreds of millions of Chinese people still endure every day.

People’s Park (人民公园) is a Chinese movie, an experimental, structuralist documentary shot in People’s Park, Chengdu, Sichuan, in one single, bravura take lasting 75 minutes by the young American directors J.P. Sniadecki (史杰鹏) and Libbie D. Cohn (张莫). The fullness of Chinese urban leisure life contrasts with the rural world Wang Bing evokes. As the camera pans side to side and glides relentlessly forward through the park, it catches hundreds of Chinese urbanites out for fun, relaxation, socializing, and a certain kind of freedom: eating, strolling, singing, practicing calligraphy, and watching each other. Watching becomes dancing as the film slowly gathers an ecstatic, trance-like groove, building to a rapturous climax, as people, movement, music, image, and sound mix together: this is as close to pure pleasure as cinema gets.

Since the dawning of the digital era, independent fiction has attracted most of China’s creatively audacious young directors. Memories Look at Me (记忆望着我), the first feature from Song Fang (宋方), is a quiet jewel made on a shoestring. The director films herself visiting her retired parents at their Nanjing home and leads us to a place somewhere between documentary and fiction as father, mother, and daughter play carefully scripted versions of themselves. Yasujiro Ozu’s Tokyo Story is in the background, but so are Liu Jiayin’s brilliant experiments in first-person family filmmaking. The film is a meditation that speaks of deep passions with the subtlest voice.

More lively is the vibrant coming-of-age film Egg and Stone (鸡蛋和石头) by young director Huang Ji (黄骥). Another women’s story, this time a troubling rural tale (all too typical, Huang tells us) of a young woman’s sexual abuse at the hands of intimate acquaintances from her village. The film, though, is no typically dour Chinese miserablist indie (a genre Western festivals do too much to encourage and perpetuate). Huang bathes her film in vivid, saturated light and color, exhibiting something akin to that unstoppable life force that animates the heroines of Three Sisters in the face of unimaginable adversity.

Quite possibly the darkest Chinese film of the year, and one of the most important, is the controversial When Night Falls (我还有话要说, a title that translates literally as I Want to Say More), by Ying Liang (应亮). Based on the real life case of Yang Jia, sentenced to death for the 2008 knifing murder of six Shanghai policemen, the film has drawn the hostile attention of Shanghai’s police, who exerted considerable pressure on the director and on the producers to suppress the film both inside and outside China. But Ying Liang, whose subtle, ironic indie films make him one of the most incisive young Chinese directors working today, has not made this an explicitly political film. Instead, he adopts an oblique, fictional mode, concentrating exclusively on the killer’s mother, Wang Jingmei (played with powerful restraint by Nai An), her struggle to understand her son’s actions and her subsequent victimization by a criminal justice system that is opaque and oppressive.

Two of the best new Chinese films this year are even more experimental in their approach. The first feature film of novelist Chai Chunya (柴春芽), Four Ways to Die in My Hometown (我故乡的四种死亡方式) is a visionary masterpiece. Burying his narrative lines deep underground, Chai builds up a series of striking tableaux, hypnotically suggestive and pictorially spectacular. Two young women lose a camel, then a father. A retired shadow puppeteer meets a gun-toting tree thief. Storytellers and shamans organize a lost spiritual world that Chai wills back to life in deeply beautiful visual motifs whose meanings lie tantalizingly just out of reach.

Emperor Visits the Hell [sic] (唐皇游地府), the black and white film from Li Luo (李珞), is another kind of narrative experiment. Li takes a sharply satiric concept and makes it seem utterly natural and brilliantly comic. He relocates an episode of the Chinese classic Journey To The West to present-day central China, to Wuhan, where the Tang Dynasty Emperor Li Shimin of the novel is now a corrupt but aesthetically refined official. Ghosts and demons become the criminal gang leaders with whom Chinese officialdom formally and informally collude to share power and amass wealth.

There is room for one strikingly innovative genre piece on my list of China’s best films of 2012: Judge Archer (箭士柳白猿), the second feature from novelist and martial arts practitioner Xu Haofeng (徐浩峰). This independently produced but officially approved wuxia film is about a master archer who adjudicates disputes in the martial arts world. In it, Xu dares to redesign martial arts cinema for the current moment. He borrows from masters Chang Cheh and King Hu but forges an entirely new, transparent, and elegantly visceral style fusing action choreography with editing, cinematography, and narrative experimentation. Xu’s film gracefully embodies what Chai Chunya implies: that radical cinema can show how the living cultural traditions seemingly destroyed by China’s rush to modernize are not only still conceivable but imaginatively re-constructable and even necessary.

Finally, two shorts announce two new directors whose work I suspect we will be following closely in the future. Gyatso Gentsu (白斌) is an ethnic Tibetan professor of art based in southwest China’s Sichuan province. His animated short “The Hunter and the Skeleton” (猎人与骷髅怪) uses eye-popping flash animation inspired by traditional thangka paintings of Buddhist deities to tell the subtly subversive story based on a folk myth of a hunter’s encounter with a fearsome skeleton monster. Next, “Female Directors” (女导演), by Yang Mingming (杨明明), is a fresh, wildly funny, and wickedly self-referential mockumentary about two young actress-directors (one played by the director herself) who turn the camera on each other, as playful cinema-guerrillas set to dismantle traditional conceptions of gender and power.

Many of the now well-known Chinese directors who have achieved a measure of commercial success—or at least the possibility of a domestic commercial release and continued festival exposure abroad—started out as independent directors. By negotiating their own compromises with the Film Bureau, most of the famous “Sixth Generation” of Chinese directors have released films in China in recent years. Notable examples include Wang Xiaoshuai’s Shanghai Dreams (青红, 2005) and Chongqing Blues (日照重庆, 2010), Zhang Yuan’s I Love You (我爱你, 2002) and Little Red Flowers (看上去很美, 2006), Lou Ye’s Mystery (浮城谜事, 2012), and a number of films by Jia Zhangke, whose first censor-approved film was The World (世界, 2005).

Despite the pressures of increased interference by the state, restricted screening opportunities, and micro-budgets, the ten films I’ve selected from 2012 (and others like them) suggest that the future of China’s cinema contains possibilities both more extensive and more daring than the mega-budget co-productions currently monopolizing media attention. Independent films invent new ways for all of us, both inside and outside of the country, to see China as it remakes itself anew several times a year, manufacturing futures faster than we can assimilate them.

A long-time Beijing resident, Shelly Kraicer is a writer, critic, and film curator, who recently returned to his native Toronto. Educated at Yale University, he has written film criticism in Cinema...


Asia Society

, a leading distributor of contemporary independent film from mainland China to audiences worldwide.


Shelly Kraicer’s Alternative Top 10 Chinese Independent Films of 2012


Three Sisters (三姊妹) by Wang Bing (王兵)

People’s Park (人民公园), by J.P. Sniadecki (史杰鹏) and Libbie D. Cohn (张莫)

Memories Look at Me (记忆望着我), by Song Fang (宋方)

Egg and Stone (鸡蛋和石头) by Huang Ji (黄骥)

When Night Falls (我还有话要说), by Ying Liang (应亮)

Four Ways to Die in My Hometown (我故乡的四种死亡方式), by Chai Chunya (柴春芽)

Emperor Visits the Hell [sic] (唐皇游地府), by Li Luo (李珞),

Judge Archer (箭士柳白猿), by Xu Haofeng (徐浩峰)

“The Hunter and the Skeleton” (猎人与骷髅怪), by Gyatso Gentsu (白斌)

“Female Directors” (女导演), by Yang Mingming (杨明明)





Zhang Yimou: ‘Even Though Our Market Is Growing Fast, We’re Still Not Satisfied’

Jonathan Landreth
Hollywood has Steven Spielberg and China has Zhang Yimou, the senior statesman of moviemaking in the People’s Republic. From Red Sorghum, his 1987 debut right out of the Beijing Film Academy, through Hero, which grossed more in America in 2002 than...



Xi Jinping on What’s Wrong with Contemporary Chinese Culture

from China Film Insider
At the Beijing Forum on Literature and Art last October, President Xi Jinping spoke to a high-level audience of arts professionals about the role of arts and culture in China. The event, along with excerpts of the October 15, 2014 speech, given in...



Jia Zhangke on Finding Freedom in China on Film

Jonathan Landreth
Jia Zhangke is among the most celebrated filmmakers China has ever produced—outside of China. His 2013 film, A Touch of Sin, a weaving-together of four tales of violence ripped from modern-day newspaper headlines, won the Best Screenplay award at...



In Zhang Yimou’s ‘Coming Home’ History is Muted But Not Silent

Eva Shan Chou
Coming Home, directed by the celebrated Zhang Yimou and released in the U.S. last week, begins as a man escapes a labor camp in China’s northwest and tries to return home. But he is captured when he and his wife attempt to meet, after their daughter...



French Director’s Chinese Movie Balances Freedom With Compromise

Jonathan Landreth
In 2012, French movie director Jean-Jacques Annaud got a warm welcome in China after more than a dozen years as persona non grata there for having offended official Chinese Communist Party history with his 1997 film Seven Years in Tibet—the story of...



The Met Goes to China

Jeffrey Wasserstrom
In July, while in New York, I toured The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s much buzzed about “China: Through the Looking Glass,” a visually stunning multimedia exhibit that showcases the varied ways that Western fashion designers have been inspired by...



Banned in China, Independent Chinese Films Come to New York

Jonathan Landreth
Three years ago this week I watched the 9th Beijing Independent Film Festival crumble under the weight of official fear—fear that the gritty low-budget, experimental dramas and documentaries screening in a remote Beijing suburb reflected a touch...



Has Chinese Film Finally Produced a Real Hero?

Ying Zhu
“This Is an Era That Calls for Heroes”—the boldface Chinese characters scream from a publicity poster for the Chinese animation film, Monkey King: Hero is Back, which made headline news in July for breaking the animation box-office record in China...



Japan’s Soft Power Leader in China is a Fat Blue Cartoon Cat

David Volodzko
On July 28, costumed in vibrant colors, throngs of fans flocked toward the early morning light of Victoria Harbor, queueing outside the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Center for the last day of the 17th Ani-Com & Games Hong Kong. The...



Chinese Writers and Chinese Reality

Ouyang Bin
My first encounter with Liu Zhenyun was in 2003. At the time, cell phones had just become available in China and they were complicating people’s relationships. I witnessed a couple break up because of the secrets stored on a phone. I watched people...