Parched Beijing’s Olympics Bid Based on Fake Snow

Undaunted by Water Shortage, Beijing Bids to Host the 2022 Winter Olympics

Where better for a Winter Olympic Games than famously arid north China?

Drought and a fast growing economy have created water shortages so severe that China’s government has spent more than a decade, and up to U.S.$80 billion, constructing 2,400 kilometers of canals and tunnels to pump 45 billion cubic meters of water from the moist south to the parched capital and surrounding areas.

Undeterred, the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympic Games campaign has already slalomed its way through the crucial first round by clinching nomination as a candidate city, with a bid wholly dependent on man-made snow.

The bid committee’s pitch to the International Olympic Committee (IOC) promises to host a “sustainable games” that promotes environmental benefits and “takes sustainable development as one of its obligations.”

Only one rival remains in the race: Almaty, in neighboring Kazakhstan. Oslo was looking a strong choice until the Norwegians mysteriously withdrew in October. Success for Beijing at the IOC’s July 31 meeting would make it the first city to host both Summer and Winter games, a double win.

Lack of snow would seem to be a major problem, even for Beijing’s expert weather managers, who used cloud seeding techniques to dump heavy summer rains away from the 2008 Olympic Games opening ceremony. In north China, the rainy season is summer.

During the mid-winter months, precipitation around Beijing averages 2.5 millimeters, too little to guarantee even a thin sprinkling. Small ski resorts near the capital use snow-making machines. One of them, Yanqing, about 90 minutes from the city, would host alpine ski events and bobsleighing.

Even local hoteliers are skeptical.“This is definitely not the best place to have a big winter activity, at least for snow sports," Fabio Ries, the General Manager of the nearby Dolomiti Mountain Resort, told the AFP news agency.

To solve this, Zhangjiakou, in northern Hebei province near Inner Mongolia, is being proposed as co-host for the majority of ski and snowboard events. Its snowfall averages one meter a year. What stays on the ground is usually less than a foot deep, still not enough.

“As there are abundant water resources near the ski resorts and the melted snow will be recycled, snow-making during the Games will not have any negative impact on the local eco-system,” according to the bid committee’s candidature file.

But where will this water come from? It seems it will be pumped from reservoirs, which means ultimately from rivers. Bid organizers say there will be no extra water demand beyond ski resorts’ existing thirst, and “very limited” impact on reservoirs.

“The water storage ponds and water delivery systems needed…[are] already in place,” the Beijing 2022 media office said in an email.

That is because of a recent construction blitz to bolster Zhangjiakou’s prospects as a ski resort, and China’s fledgling ski industry. Work will finish this year on the Yunzhou Reservoir water diversion project, capable of diverting 5 million tonnes of water annually; its main storage pond is at Changchengling in the Games Zone. Yunzhou will supply 360,000 cubic meters of water for snowmaking.

However, Zhangjiakou’s famously fragile ecosystem has attracted an avalanche of researchers. Declining rainfall since 1997 and rising temperatures—up 0.4 degrees Celsius each decade since 1960 and 0.68 degrees in winter—has depleted the Qingshui River and led to overexploitation of ground water, according to a study in the Chinese Journal of Agrometeorology.

Water scarcity is so problematic that the city was the focus of experiments to increase the “productivity of limited water resources through rational water use allocation” by environmental scientists from Beijing Normal University.

The bid committee’s Environmental Impact Assessment acknowledges some risks, including, “Possible damage to vegetation, soil disturbance, impact on the habitat of some birds and dust and noise pollution” in all three zones—Yanqing, Zhangjiakou, and Beijing.

Not mentioned, though surely inevitable, is the heat island effect of building hotels, leisure facilities, and conference centers to house the games, and the longer-term stresses on groundwater they will bring if the event is to deliver the promised 20% boost to local GDP.

Beijing’s smog has worsened since the 2008 games created worldwide awareness of China’s rapid modernization and, less happily, its toxic air quality prompted embarrassing rows about how athletes could protect themselves.

The Beijing 2022 bid is highlighting environmental commitments, promising a green games.

Pledges include changing the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region’s energy mix, better air quality, and a carbon neutral games, partly achieved by planting 70,000 hectares of trees to create “carbon sinks” and protect watersheds.

“Sustainability will be implemented in all aspects of Beijing 2022; clean energies will be developed and energy-saving and eco-friendly technologies and products will be applied extensively,” the candidature file says. Specifics include renewable energy at 15 new Olympic venues, and 540 clean energy buses for Zhangjiakou.

National Policies

However, some of the more dramatic pledges, such as the promise to slash annual regional coal use from 23 million tonnes to less than 10 million tonnes, simply reiterate existing policy targets. For instance, “Beijing is making every effort to carry out the Clean Air Action Plan 2013-2017.”

Just as with the 2008 hosting, national economic development is a central goal. China is now a majority urban nation, so experiments in better coordination between cities have become a priority. One such area is the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region, declared a project within the National Strategy of Integrated and Coordinated Development in a February 2014 document.

Developing the nouveau riche winter sports market is another aim. The bid committee says, “the Olympic Winter Games will be utilized to accelerate the construction of the Beijing-Zhangjiakou Sport, Culture and Tourism Belt.”

Chinese winter sports enthusiasts will be joyful, even without natural snow. Shen Long, a 40-something designer from Beijing, has skied in Zhangjiakou and on fresh powder in France. Although the latter was “much better,” he says man-made snow will be fine, as pressed snow is needed for racing, adding that a win for Beijing would be “wonderful.”